Finest Collection Free shipping on order over $500 Shop Now Hide filtersShow filters Default sorting Sort by popularity Sort by average rating Sort by latest Sort by price: low to high Sort by price: high to low Showing 1–20 of 310 results Buffalo NickelExonumia & Other × Close Cateories Buffalo NickelExonumia & Other Search Denomination 1 12 Shillings & 6 Pence 2 10 10C 25C 35 128 5 Million Mark 500 2500 30C 50 5C Envelope Nickel Pins Scripophily £2 & 10 Shillings £6.05 Price Under $25.00 $25.00 - $100.00 $100.00 - $500.00 $500.00 - $1,000.00 Over $1,000.00 1913-D Type 2 Buffalo Nickel 4W62$135.00 1937 Buffalo Nickel BU 4OEX$42.00 1936 Buffalo Nickel BU 4OF2$42.00 1931-S Buffalo Nickel XF 3ANY$32.00 1924-S Buffalo Nickel 4OF4$33.00 1924-D Buffalo Nickel 4OF5$25.00 1924 Buffalo Nickel AU 4OF6$38.00 1921-S Buffalo Nickel 4OF7$77.00 1921 Buffalo Nickel XF 4OF8$50.00 1920-D Buffalo Nickel 4GP3$16.00 1919-S Buffalo Nickel 4GP4$42.00 1919 Buffalo Nickel XF 4GP5$16.00 1918-D Buffalo Nickel 4GP6$50.00 1917-D Buffalo Nickel 4GP7$42.00 1916-S Buffalo Nickel 4GP8$44.00 1914-D Buffalo Nickel 4GP9$77.00 Gold Star Lapel Button E I F Authorized Act of Congress 1 August 1947 4OEA$15.00 1924-S Buffalo Nickel 48WO$72.00 1935 Buffalo Nickel Cherrypickers FS-801 DDR Five Cents 416X$94.00 1913-S Type 1 Buffalo Nickel 4171$38.00